Tuesday, April 17, 2007

The Practicing Progressive

Issue 18
April 16, 2007

He shook his head, smiled, and dismissed a whole religion with, “And to think they believe Mohammed rode up to heaven on a horse!”

And to think we believe that a man actually rose from the dead.

Another poor Richard once reminded us that people in glass houses should be careful about what they say about other religions.

I’ve always liked the Sundays after Easter when we gain a little distance from the mythology and move a little closer to the truth. During Holy Week, a friend of mine signed his e-mail to me: “Christ is risen! (Existentially, of course.)

Several years ago, while hosting a seminar with Bishop John Spong, I received a letter from a fellow Lutheran pastor who chastised me for inviting someone “who doesn’t believe in the historical resurrection of Jesus.” I marveled at the gall of my correspondent, who, I suppose, isn’t interested in theological perspectives different than his own. I also wondered just what his theological perspective might be. I assumed he clung to the conviction that Jesus did, in fact and in body, walk out of the tomb that long ago Sunday.

As we seek to construct a Christianity for the modern mind, it is fair to ask whether literalistic declarations regarding the resurrection are either instructive or helpful. Must we have this particular form of divine authentication for Jesus’ teachings to be true? We need a physical resurrection only to validate Christianity’s thesis of atonement. Paul’s bold declaration that our faith is in vain without Jesus rising from the dead holds no power for many of us. Our commitment to the teachings of Jesus is not voided by our rejection of his physical resurrection.

A number of years ago, several members of my parish passed a book onto me that had captured their imaginations. The novel’s central theme was the discovery of the bones of Jesus in an ancient tomb outside of Jerusalem. The realization that Jesus hadn’t actually risen from the dead sent the entire world into turmoil, hurtling us toward an apocalyptic end. Thankfully, at the last minute, the bones were proven to be not those of Jesus and the world was saved from extinction. Whew! I found it, to say the least, a bit overwrought. This was pre-The Da Vinci Code or the recent claim to have found the ossuary of Jesus but it still shook up my congregants. What if the resurrection isn’t a fact of history? Would Christianity (let alone the world as we know it) come to a screeching halt? Not for me and, I suspect, not for millions of others who have found the teachings of Jesus to be a guide to discovering a life of meaning, purpose and, yes, even hope…with or without the bodily resurrection.

Ironically, there is no more powerful symbol of authentic Christianity for me than that of death and resurrection. The reality that life is a series of dyings and risings proclaims a truth that resonates deep within. “The only constant is change” someone who must have understood the metaphor of resurrection once said. All of us, sometimes very reluctantly, know that is true.

Curiously, Christianity has too often demanded acceptance of Jesus’ physical rising while missing the power of the metaphor. No institution is more resistant to the little deaths and resurrections that comprise a healthy understanding of life than the church. It is a sad paradox that insisting on a literalistic understanding of the resurrection of Jesus prevents many inquisitive Christians from experiencing the true power of the resurrection.

Monday, April 09, 2007

The Practicing Progressive

Issue 17
April 9, 2007

A man I very much admire included this verse from the new Lutheran Hymnal in his Easter message:

Come to the table of mercy, prepared with the wine and the bread.
All who are hungry and thirsty, come and your souls will be fed.
Come at the Lord's invitation; receive from his nail-scarred hand.
Eat of the blood of salvation; drink of the blood of the Lamb.


I believe I understand and appreciate his message but I find his method, well, repugnant. Surely there are more theologically authentic ways of announcing God’s grace than ones that rely on this strange, and repulsive to many, obsession with blood.

I know, I know, blood is the source and symbol of life, the nectar of the gods, without it we could be folded up and carried in a suitcase, etc.…I know all that but I still don’t like it. And I continue to wonder why it maintains such a hold on Christians.

In a recent interview, Wes Craven, a movie director who has nearly perfected the blood-drenched horror film with “Nightmare on Elm Street” and “Scream”, was asked about his profuse use of blood in his movies. He immediately began to talk of Christianity and its fascination with that same bodily fluid. He was enthralled, he said, by the fact that Christians drink it, save it, wear it, sing about it and more…and concluded his own obsession with it couldn’t be all that abnormal.

He may be right but I never go to horror films and I can only watch violent-prone movies through the gaps in my fingers clasped tight across my face. (Many years ago, I was working on a film as an assistant make-up man. The scene we were shooting that day took place in a bar and involved a machine-gunning massacre. I was assigned the job of filling condoms with stage blood, tying them off, attaching a small electrode to the tip and then taping these blood-filled beauties onto the actors who were about to be executed. This important work took the good part of the day and involved lots of laughter and black humor. But when the time came to shoot the scene and the machine guns went off and the blood burst forth, I had to put my head between my knees to keep from fainting at the sight of all that FAKE blood!) So you see I’m probably not the most objective critic here. Nevertheless, I believe I speak for more than just me on this common albeit disturbing Christian image and can offer a helpful criticism or two.

For instance, if we have moved away from the bizarre theory of Jesus having to appease God by atoning for the sins of humankind by being tortured and slowly killed, isn’t it about time we carefully scrutinize our liturgy and hymnody for vestiges of that discarded understanding? Certainly the death of Jesus must have been a bloody affair and, yes, the image of that blood letting is a powerful one as we ponder its unjust occasion but must we continue to equate Jesus’ loss of blood with our spiritual gain? Besides, didn’t Mel Gibson do enough of that already?

On this past Palm Sunday, I listened to a carefully constructed sermon that had as its main thesis the proclamation that “Jesus didn’t die for the sins of the world but because of the sins of the world.” The preacher made clear his conviction that Jesus’ death was not ordained by God but was the result of a commitment to live a Godly life, a life of compassion. It was, I thought, a most helpful invitation into Holy Week. Unfortunately, the liturgy in which this sermon sat was filled with very different images. Over and over again, the hymns that were sung resonated with the archaic atonement thinking that the preacher had just rebuked.

I recognize that the wheels of change turn slowly, especially those bearing the church, but surely I was not the only one who was troubled and confused by the incongruity. The time has come for our liturgy to support our theology. Sentiment should not be confused with sanctity. Much of what we continue to cling to in Christian worship has little to do with assisting Christians in the world today. It is time to move on.

Humbly, I offer a revised version of my friend’s lyrical Easter sentiment with the hope we continue to find new ways of proclaiming the authentic message of Jesus:

Come to the table of welcome, prepared with the wine and the bread.
All who are searching and seeking; hear what the master once said.
Come at the Lord's invitation; receive from his compassionate soul
The gift of a joyous friendship; the gift of a life made whole.

Tuesday, March 27, 2007

The Practicing Progressive

Issue 16
March 27, 2007

I am sure that Richard Mau, president of Fuller Theological Seminary, is a kind and compassionate man. I also understand that he has a reputation as an enlightened evangelical with an ecumenical spirit and oratorical skill. I have no reason to doubt any of this but I believe his theology is intellectually bankrupt.

I come to this conclusion after one late-night listening to Mau’s comments on NPR’s “Talk of the Nation” radio call-in show. You can listen to his remarks right now: http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=9041745 . Perhaps you will come to another conclusion but I found his responses to host Neal Conan’s questions, as well as those of some listeners, revelatory of the strange convoluted exegesis that evangelicals often employ.

“As a Christian who takes the Bible seriously…” Mau prefaces his remarks and then goes on to claim that his view should be honored and not dismissed as the ranting of a homophobe. Yet he sidesteps criticism that his reliance on the Bible for his position is neither coherent nor consistent. Why, one wonders, does he not keep a kosher diet or demand that women remain silent in church or support the continuation of slavery…all of which receive emphasis in the Bible.

I suspect that Mau is justifiably fearful of the slippery slope that exists for those who are willing to consider the voluminous and very credible research available on the formation of the Bible. Once one begins to muse over the possibility that particular scriptural passages might reflect more of the tenor of the times than the actual desires of the divine, one confronts a radically different approach to the Bible. Mau, and others like him, are afraid of the ultimate destination of such thinking. And so they should. Simply by reflecting, as he does on this show, on the pain that his position causes to homosexuals, Mau begins the process of realizing that the compassionate life modeled by Jesus supersedes even scripture. This is a very dangerous position for an evangelical Christian to ponder and so, at least on this show, Mau relies on the biblical bromides that substitute for intellectual insight among conservative Christianity.

As I listened to the show, I grew more and more irritated with Mau’s intellectual dishonesty. His protestations of compassion rang hollow next to his unwillingness to confront the incongruities in his exegesis. One questioner wondered if such faulty thinking should even be given a voice any longer. The caller cited the fact that misogyny and racism were no longer considered worthy positions of public debate. Why, he asked, is homophobia? Although both the host and the guests quickly dismissed the caller’s question, it bears some consideration. Considerable time and energy have been wasted in certain school systems, for instance, on the ludicrous biblical interpretations that seek to pass as science. Is it not time to do the same with this kind of intellectual inconsistency that passes as Christian pastoral care?

I have a hunch that Mr. Mau is very much aware of the tenuous nature of his reasoning but I also suspect that he is concerned where a more consistent pattern of thought might take him. As president of a prestigious evangelical seminary, Mau knows full well the political ramifications of a more honest position. Sadly, it appears, he would rather risk his intellectual reputation than his institutional support. Choosing a fraudulent line of reasoning, Mau has indicated his willingness to choose the clamoring crowd over the compassionate Christ.